Our Money-Back Guarantee

Shiloh and the Western Campaign of 1862

by , ,

The bloody and decisive two-day battle of Shiloh (April 6-7, 1862) changed the entire course of the American Civil War. The stunning Northern victory ... Show synopsis

Find your copy

Change currency

Reviews of Shiloh and the Western Campaign of 1862

Average rating
4.000
4 out of 5 stars
  • In-depth analysis of campaign and battle Sep 25, 2007
    by Donogh

    Having not read another book on the Battle of Shiloh, I can't comment on whether this work is better or more important than previous work on the subject.
    I am very surprised that only four books have been written before. The fact that this is a previously unpublished dissertation which experts adjudge to be the most important and complete work on the battle surprised me even more.
    The editors of the book, Gary Joiner and Timothy Smith, have made a few changes to the original text, and are very careful to explain every significant change they have made.
    The maps (by Gary Joiner) are quite good, although they do give a strong impression of being made with computer software not completely familiar to the user. I would have liked more detail on the units involved though. I would say that, while not quite up to the standard I normally expect from Savas Beatie, they're still superior to the maps you usually find.
    Cunningham begins by giving us some in-depth background to the campaign, not a background to the war, but serious arguments as to why both sides were eager to control the Mississipi and its tributaries, the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers.
    Coming up to the battle, attention is given to the intentions and concerns (or lack of concern) of the generals. Here where so many authors might have planted a flagpole on the pro/con-Grant argument, Cunningham allows the participants actions and words to speak for themselves.
    So too, serious amounts of ink are spilled in discussing the respective experience of both armies and their generals.
    When we get to the battle itself, several things become clear; Cunningham has walked the ground, and has poured through the primary sources.
    He is very careful in analysing exactly what (insofar as is possible in this chaotic battle) occured in all sections of the battlefield.
    While other historians have apparently spent a lot of time on one particular facet of the battle, Cunningham applies an even hand, and it is obvious, though never explicit, that he thinks the chaos of the battle is its most significant aspect.
    He finished with a careful, though short, appraisal of the Corinth operation which followed.
    I would have hoped for more explicit summation of why the battle went the way it did, and some weighing of generals' performance on each side. That said, I would recommend this book easily.

See all reviews of Shiloh and the Western Campaign of 1862 by O Edward Cunningham, Gary D Joiner (Editor), Timothy B Smith (Editor)

Get $300 in coupons and other goodies. Sign up for newsletter No, thank you.

You're signed up (and we you). Watch for our Welcome e-mail and your first coupon. Thanks!